One shot, two benefits!

Doctor preparing an influenza vaccine for a patient.

To try and boost sales during the pandemic many businesses are offering two-for-one deals; buy one product get another free. Well, that might also be the case with a flu shot; get one jab and get protection from two viruses.

A new study offers an intriguing – though not yet certain – suggestion that getting a flu shot could not only reduce your risk of getting the flu, but also help reduce your risk of contracting the coronavirus. If it’s true it would be a wonderful tool for health professionals hoping to head of a twindemic of flu and COVID-19 this winter. It would also be a pretty sweet deal for the rest of us.

Researchers at Radboud University Medical Center in the Netherlands looked through their hospital’s database and compared people who got a flu shot during the previous year with people who didn’t. They found that people who got the vaccine were 39 percent less likely to have tested positive for the coronavirus than people who didn’t get the vaccine.

Now, there are a bunch of caveats about this study (published in the preprint journal MedRxiv) one of which is that it wasn’t peer reviewed. Another is that people who get flu shots might just be more health conscious than people who don’t, which means they might also be more aware of the need to wear a mask, social distance, wash their hands etc.

But that doesn’t mean this study is wrong. Two recent studies (in the journal Vaccines and the Journal of Medical Virology) also found similar findings, that people over the age of 65 who got a flu shot had a lower risk of getting COVID-19. That’s particularly important for that age group as they are the ones most likely to experience life-threatening complications from COVID-19.

But what could explain getting a two-fer from one vaccine? Well, there’s a growing body of research that points to something called “trained innate immunity”. Our bodies have two different kinds of immune system, adaptive and innate. Vaccines activate the adaptive system, causing it to develop antibodies to attack and kill a virus. But there’s also evidence these same vaccines could trigger our innate immune system to help fight off infections. So, a flu vaccine could boost your adaptive immunity against the flu, but also kick in the innate immunity against the coronavirus.

In an article in Scientific American, Ellen Foxman, an immunobiologist and clinical pathologist at the Yale School of Medicine, says that might be the case here: “There is evidence from the literature that trained immunity does exist and can offer broad protection, in unexpected ways, against other pathogens besides what the vaccine was designed against.”

The researchers in the Netherlands wanted to see if there was any evidence that what they saw in their hospital had any basis in fact. So, they devised a simple experiment. They took blood cells from healthy individuals and exposed some of the cells to the flu vaccine. After six days they exposed all the cells to the SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.

Compared to the untreated cells, the cells that had been exposed to the flu vaccine produced more virus-fighting immune molecules called cytokines. These can attack the virus and help protect people early on, resulting in a milder, less dangerous infection.

All in all it’s encouraging evidence that a flu shot might help protect you against the coronavirus. And at the very least it will reduce your risk of the flu, and if there’s one thing you definitely don’t want this year it’s having to battle two life-threatening viruses at the same time.

2 thoughts on “One shot, two benefits!

  1. Nothing like anecdotes for scientific evidence. My wife and I had flu shots in 2019. In March 2020, we both contracted covid. Operative words in much of the covid research are “may,” “could,” “possibly,” “might” and other expressions that signal that all of what is being related “may” not be accurate or true.

  2. In human, there are two types of immune response during the infection of pathogens. Innate immunity or so-called nonspecific defense mechanism that take place immediately or within hours of antigens appearance in the body. White blood cells such as basophils, dendretic cells, eosinophils, Langerhans cells, mast cells, monocytes, macrophages, neutrophil and NK cells are recruited to destroy the invaders. However, different groups of phagocytic cells have different sensitivities to recognize conserved features of pathogens for destruction. These pathogen-associated molecules not only activate phagocytic cells for proliferation and maturation but inflammatory response which can disrupt membrane of micro-organism. The disadvantage of innate immunity for being recognize only the relatively few microbial structures that are highly conserved and being unable to elvolvo as rapidly as micro-organisms do. On the other hand, adaptive immunity involves mostly of T and B lymphocytes, they remember previous encounters with specific pathogen. The immunity takes a slow time to develop on first exposure to new pathogen.

    People take a flu-shot might induce innate immunity which activate, proliferation and maturation of immune cells. Evidence proved that stimulation of nonspecific immunity is very depended on maturation of immune cells to reduce the incident of upper respiratory infection in children. The great numbers of mature immune cells provide an additional advantage for patient to overcome the infection of Covid-19. However, innate immunity is effective and potential to eradicate small numbers of virus or early stage of virus infection but unable to completely eradicate all the virus or virus with high transmission rate. Therefore, a flu-shot does not protect the people from double infections from both flu-like and Covid-19.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.